Raising the minimum wage is a bad idea

"Support for a minimum wage hike is about pandering to the masses, not about policies that will actually benefit workers."


If you would like to see concrete, real-world evidence that government’s wage control policies are a bad idea, Venezuela just produced the perfect example.

As the South American country enters yet another dark period of its long battle against liberty, President Nicolas Maduro’s minimum wage rules, which increased the salary by nearly 3,500 percent at once, has wiped out 40 percent of the country’s stores.

Firms that had been struggling to stay afloat thanks to Maduro’s ongoing war on business finally succumbed, claiming that the outrageous wage increase finally put them out of business. Others that managed to remain open are only doing so to liquidate their merchandise so they can then close completely once all is gone.

According to Maria Carolina Uzcátegui, president of the National Council of Commerce and Services of Venezuela, the situation has turned into a dead end for business owners.

“It is a perfect storm,” Uzcátegui said. “These decisions are leading many business people to say, ‘No, I can’t do it anymore.’”

The obvious and immediate consequence of this wage increase is the rapid rise in unemployment, as a massive number of employers are no longer able to provide jobs. But the job loss was to be expected, as Maduro explicitly ignored the laws of economics once again, thinking he could ignore supply and demand by mandating artificial economic growth.

In the Philippines and the United States, politicians have long defended direct meddling in the economy, supporting wage control laws and pushing for higher minimum wages

The US Democratic Party’s 2016 platform proposed a national minimum wage of $15 an hour. At the time, even Hillary Clinton admitted the new rules would lead to job losses, and yet, Democrats today continue to defend the plan.

Recently, Democratic socialist and congresswoman Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez visited New York City’s iconic cafe, the Coffee Shop, at Union Square, after the firm announced it was shutting its doors after 28 years of service. The cafe said that it could no longer stay in business after Governor Andrew Cuomo’s minimum wage hike and yet, Ocasio-Cortez, who worked at the cafe at some point, continues to claim she will not rest “until every person in this country is paid a living wage to lead a dignified life.”

But despite the rhetoric, support for a minimum wage hike is about pandering to the masses, not about policies that will actually benefit workers. Even major left-leaning outlets such as the Washington Post have concluded that rapid increases in the minimum wage in certain counties would cost thousands of jobs. Unfortunately, the madness continues.


Economists Walter E. Williams and Thomas Sowell have long explained that government’s wage rules have a very real consequence: To disproportionately hurt the youth, the unskilled, and minorities.

As Williams wrote, racist unions in South Africa during the apartheid period, for example, were the most passionate defenders of minimum wage laws for blacks, as they wanted to make it difficult for natives to be employed.

“‘Equal pay for equal work’ became the rallying slogan of the South African white labor movement,” Williams explained. “These laborers knew that if employers were forced to pay black workers the same wages as white workers, there’d be reduced incentive to hire blacks.”

Today, a major minimum wage hike would have the same effect, killing jobs and hurting the youth, the unskilled, and minority communities the most. But despite this reality, so-called social justice warriors and the left have no problem defending and promising to push the policy through whenever possible.

In no time, the Philippines could look a lot like Venezuela—if the left and business-hating bureaucrats continue to get their way.


In an interview on Meet the Press, US Democratic socialist and congresswoman Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez scolded American leaders for not setting the minimum wage as high as Venezuela, whose hyper-inflated currency is forcing minimum wage increases all year long.

Ocasio-Cortez then pointed out that if the minimum wage would just be raised to somewhere in the millions like the socialist South American country did, everyone will be a millionaire.

“Venezula’s minimum wage is, like, millions per month, and ours isn’t even close to that,” she said. “Our minimum wage is, like, seven bucks an hour or something. We call ourselves a developed country, but we don’t even just like print nearly as much money as Venezuela and give it out for free, because of greedy businesses and corporations and things like that.”

She also called Venezuela’s leaders “really smart” for overloading the economy with more currency, and called on America’s leadership to do the same. “It just goes to show that socialism is better because you can inflate the currency to a lot more, and more is better than less, obviously.”

“It’s just common sense, and you know, like, human rights and stuff,” she added.

[email protected]

Topics: Eric Jurado , minimum wage , Venezuela , President Nicolas Maduro
COMMENT DISCLAIMER: Reader comments posted on this Web site are not in any way endorsed by Manila Standard. Comments are views by readers who exercise their right to free expression and they do not necessarily represent or reflect the position or viewpoint of While reserving this publication’s right to delete comments that are deemed offensive, indecent or inconsistent with Manila Standard editorial standards, Manila Standard may not be held liable for any false information posted by readers in this comments section.
AdvertisementSpeaker GMA