Tuesday, August 16, 2022
manilastandard.net
ADVERTISEMENT
  • About
  • News
    • Top Stories
    • National
    • World News
    • Pinoy Abroad
    • Features
  • Opinion
    • Editorial
    • Columns
    • Soundbytes
  • LGUs
    • NCR
    • Luzon
    • Visayas
    • Mindanao
  • Business
    • Corporate
    • Economy & Trade
    • Stocks
    • Money
    • Agri & Mining
    • Power & Tech
    • IT & Telecom
  • Sports
    • Basketball
    • Volleyball
    • Fightsports
    • Active
    • Sports Plus
    • One Championship
    • Columns
  • Entertainment
    • TV & Movies
    • Celebrity Profiles
    • Music & Concerts
    • Digital Media
    • Columns
  • Lifestyle
    • Food
    • Culture & Media
    • Fashion
    • Health and Home
    • Leisure
    • Shopping
    • Columns
  • Others
    • Pets
    • Pop.Life
      • Newsmakers
      • Hangouts
      • A-Pop
      • Post Its
      • Performances
      • Malls & Bazaars
      • Hobbies & Collections
    • Technology
      • Gadgets
      • Computers
      • Business
      • Tech Plus
    • MS ON THE ROAD
      • Sedan
      • SUV
      • Truck
      • Bike
      • Accessories
      • Motoring Plus
      • Commuter’s Corner
    • Home & Design
      • Residential
      • Commercial
      • Construction
      • Interior
    • Spotlight
    • Gallery
      • Photos
      • Videos
    • Events
      • Seminars
      • Exhibits
      • Community
    • Biyahero
      • Travel Features
      • Travel Reels
      • Travel Logs
  • Advertise with Us
No Result
View All Result
  • About
  • News
    • Top Stories
    • National
    • World News
    • Pinoy Abroad
    • Features
  • Opinion
    • Editorial
    • Columns
    • Soundbytes
  • LGUs
    • NCR
    • Luzon
    • Visayas
    • Mindanao
  • Business
    • Corporate
    • Economy & Trade
    • Stocks
    • Money
    • Agri & Mining
    • Power & Tech
    • IT & Telecom
  • Sports
    • Basketball
    • Volleyball
    • Fightsports
    • Active
    • Sports Plus
    • One Championship
    • Columns
  • Entertainment
    • TV & Movies
    • Celebrity Profiles
    • Music & Concerts
    • Digital Media
    • Columns
  • Lifestyle
    • Food
    • Culture & Media
    • Fashion
    • Health and Home
    • Leisure
    • Shopping
    • Columns
  • Others
    • Pets
    • Pop.Life
      • Newsmakers
      • Hangouts
      • A-Pop
      • Post Its
      • Performances
      • Malls & Bazaars
      • Hobbies & Collections
    • Technology
      • Gadgets
      • Computers
      • Business
      • Tech Plus
    • MS ON THE ROAD
      • Sedan
      • SUV
      • Truck
      • Bike
      • Accessories
      • Motoring Plus
      • Commuter’s Corner
    • Home & Design
      • Residential
      • Commercial
      • Construction
      • Interior
    • Spotlight
    • Gallery
      • Photos
      • Videos
    • Events
      • Seminars
      • Exhibits
      • Community
    • Biyahero
      • Travel Features
      • Travel Reels
      • Travel Logs
  • Advertise with Us
No Result
View All Result
manilastandard.net
No Result
View All Result
Home Opinion Columns Eagle eyes by Tony La Vina

The Enrile cases

Tony La ViñabyTony La Viña
February 16, 2016, 12:01 am
in Eagle eyes by Tony La Vina
Reading Time: 5 mins read
A A
94
SHARES
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on Email

As part of my storytelling to my students on the martial law era and the Edsa revolution,  on the occasion of the 30th anniversary of the latter on the 25th of this month, I tell my law students the story about the many cases decided by the Supreme Court that has Juan Ponce Enrile named as respondent/defendant against charges of violating human rights or petitioner invoking the same constitutional rights he was previously charged with breaching. I share these stories through a series of three to four columns, starting with this one.

Enrile was martial law administrator of the Marcos government and co-leader of the military uprising that led to the 1986 people power revolt. He is currently a sitting senator of the republic, detained and facing charges for corruption related to the Priority Development Assistance Fund scandal. He has just been released on bail for humanitarian considerations.

The cases involving Enrile tell us a lot about our country, our history in particular and how justice continues to elude us. At the end of this series, on the week we celebrate the Edsa revolution, I will reflect on what this failure means and where this could take us in the 2016 May elections when Bongbong Marcos could conceivably win as vice president.

Let me start with the  leading case of Aquino Jr. v. Enrile, decided by the Supreme Court in 1974. When martial law was proclaimed in September 21, 1972, Senator Benigno Aquino, Jr., together with Ramon Mitra Jr., Francisco Rodrigo, and Napoleon Rama, the stalwarts of the opposition fighting against the dictatorship, were arrested and held pursuant to General Order No. 2 of the President (September 22, 1972), “for being participants or for having given aid and comfort in the conspiracy to seize political and state power in the country and to take over the government by force. 

Aquino and colleagues filed petitions for habeas corpus. But while eventually all the petitioners were either permitted to withdraw their petitions or released from detention subject to certain restrictions, Aquino remained in detention. In fact, formal charges of murder, subversion and illegal possession of firearms were lodged against him forcing him to challenge the jurisdiction of the Military Commission trying him. 

ADVERTISEMENT

Faced with Aquino’s remaining legal challenge, the court had to confront the issue of whether or not the court could inquire into the validity of Proclamation No. 1081. Put more simply, is the question political or justiciable in character? Paraphrased another way, are not the issues raised in the petitions related to the propriety or constitutional sufficiency of the issuance of the proclamation purely political, which are not for the Judiciary, but for the people and the political departments of the government to determine?

Five justices, namely, Justices Makasiar, Antonio, Esguerra, Fernandez and Aquino held that the question was political and therefore its determination was beyond the jurisdiction of the High Court. Arrayed on the side of justiciability were four justices including Justices Castro, Fernando, Teehankee and Muñoz Palma who held that the constitutional sufficiency of the proclamation may be inquired into by the Highest Court. 

Justice Barredo, on the other hand, believed that political questions were not per se beyond the Court’s jurisdiction, but that as a matter of policy implicit in the Constitution itself the Court should abstain from interfering with the Executive’s proclamation.

Justice Makalintal who penned the decision sided with non-justiciability when he opined that the political-or-justiciable-question controversy has become moot and purposeless as a consequence of the general referendum of July 27-28, 1973. With the ruling of non-justiciability having attained the majority vote, the High Court decided to dismiss all petitions. 

An interesting side story of this case involved Senator Jose W. Diokno. He was one of the original petitioners but later he withdrew from the case, stating that he had lost confidence in the Supreme Court after it ruled that the 1973 Constitution was in effect.

Almost 10 years later, the Supreme Court would revisit the issue of illegal detentions in Garcia-Padilla v. Enrile. In 1982, Sabino Padilla and eight others out of the 14 detainees were then having a conference in the dining room at Dr. Parong’s residence. These individuals, together with a few others totaling 14, were previously under surveillance by the authorities as they were suspected of engaging in subversive activities being members of the Communist Party of the Philippines. It was during this meeting that they were arrested by the Philippine Constabulary by authority of a Presidential Commitment Order and brought to an undisclosed location. 

Not knowing the whereabouts of her son Sabino, Josefina Padilla, went to the Court praying for the issuance of a writ of habeas corpus to direct respondents then-Minister of National Defense Enrile, Gen. Fabian Ver, Gen. Fidel Ramos and Lt. Col. Colonel to produce the bodies of the missing individuals. 

In the resolution of the Court, the writ of habeas corpus was issued and respondents were required to make a return of the writ. At the hearing of the petition, the Solicitor General contended that the so-named persons were arrested and are being detained for offenses with respect to which under Proclamation No. 2045, the privilege of the writ of habeas corpus continues to be suspended; in effect saying that the privilege of the writ of habeas corpus is unavailing as to them. Hence, courts cannot inquire into the validity and cause of their arrest and detention. 

Before the Court, the legality of the Presidential Commitment Order was put in issue. 

Speaking for the majority of the Court, Justice De Castro said that the arrest of persons involved in the rebellion whether as its fighting armed elements, or for committing non-violent acts but in furtherance of the rebellion, is more an act of capturing them in the course of an armed conflict, to quell the rebellion, than for the purpose of immediately prosecuting them in court for a statutory offense. Hence, according to J. De Castro, the arrest and detention of persons ordered by the President through the issuance of Presidential Commitment Order PCO is merely preventive. The majority further stated that a Presidential Commitment Order, the issuance of which is the exclusive prerogative of the President under the Constitution, may not be declared void by the courts, under the doctrine of “political question.”

Disagreeing with the majority, Justice Teehankee opined that notwithstanding the suspension of the privilege of the writ of habeas corpus, the higher and superior mandate of the Constitution guarantees the right to bail and vests the courts with the jurisdiction and judicial power to grant bail which may not be removed nor diminished nor abdicated. 

My next column will summarize next the infamous ruling of Ilagan vs. Enrile. Decided in 1985, a year before the revolution, that case justified the continuing detention of three Davao lawyers for crimes they did not commit.

Facebook: Dean Tony La Vina Twitter: tonylavs

Tags: Dean Tony La ViñaThe Enrile cases
ADVERTISEMENT
Tony La Viña

Tony La Viña

Related Posts

Consolidating the Marcos dictatorship

byTony La Viña
August 16, 2022, 12:05 am
0
481
Denying Villafuerte justice

"The logical consequence therefore is that President Marcos is a de jure President of the Republic of the Philippines" In...

Read more

The Aquino cases

byTony La Viña
August 13, 2022, 12:10 am
0
1.1k
Denying Villafuerte justice

"In questioning the jurisdiction of the military commission, petitioner Benigno Aquino Jr. insisted he was a civilian and his trial...

Read more

Gilbert Son, missionary of hope

byTony La Viña
August 9, 2022, 12:05 am
0
861
Denying Villafuerte justice

"It is important to have an adult itinerary of faith, so that believers, with the grace of God, step by...

Read more

FVR’s template of good governance

byTony La Viña
August 6, 2022, 12:10 am
0
395
Denying Villafuerte justice

"FVR reminds us that we can be a great country and not the bickering, conflict-driven, and disunited nation that Marcos,...

Read more

Sickness unto death

byTony La Viña
August 2, 2022, 12:05 am
0
958
Denying Villafuerte justice

"I protest the suffering and deaths of my friends but I am also surprised by the beauty of their lives...

Read more

Terrible disinformation on Furigay killing

byTony La Viña
July 30, 2022, 12:05 am
0
1.3k
Hold the line together

"There is no justification for what suspect Dr. Chiao Tiao Yumul did and it must be condemned by all men...

Read more

Stories you may like

  • People …are talking about Liza Soberano

    Supermodel son is Philippine bet in Manhunt International

    12006 shares
    Share 4802 Tweet 3002
  • Another oil price rollback likely as world economy further stalls

    1427 shares
    Share 571 Tweet 357
  • Judgments and their execution

    1285 shares
    Share 514 Tweet 321
  • Basilan solon wants barangay, SK polls reset to May 2024 to save P8b for gov’t

    1114 shares
    Share 446 Tweet 279
  • SMART/MVP-PH Team joins ‘22 Asian Taekwondo Championship

    1039 shares
    Share 416 Tweet 260

Print Edition

View More

Recent Posts

  • Caloocan cleans senior citizen database, targets more efficient distribution of benefits
  • JICA graces turnover of access road, banana plantation project in Ifugao
  • World of DoubleDragon Corporation
  • Sneakers for Makati : AB4.0
  • Net zero, Russia war driving nascent hydrogen economy
  • What to Expect at The Outlook 2022: Philippine Real Estate Conference
  • PLDT, Smart bolster commitment to national disaster resilience
  • UN envoy makes first visit to Myanmar

Advertisement

Latest News

What to Expect at The Outlook 2022: Philippine Real Estate Conference

byManila Standard
August 16, 2022, 1:20 pm
0
131
What to Expect at The Outlook 2022: Philippine Real Estate Conference

The much-anticipated event The Outlook 2022: Philippine Real Estate Conference will happen on August 31, 2022. The in-person conference will...

Read more

PLDT, Smart bolster commitment to national disaster resilience

byManila Standard
August 16, 2022, 1:20 pm
0
133
PLDT, Smart bolster commitment to national disaster resilience

PLDT and Smart ramp up their commitment of building a resilient Philippines. Through one of its core advocacies called #SafeandSmart,...

Read more

UN envoy makes first visit to Myanmar

byAFP
August 16, 2022, 1:00 pm
0
134
Southwoods nails Seniors’ Fil golf crown

The UN's new special envoy for Myanmar began her first trip to the country Tuesday, a day after a junta...

Read more

Chinese ship docks in Sri Lanka despite India, US concerns

byAFP
August 16, 2022, 12:30 pm
0
161
‘No use worrying’: Taiwanese tourists carry on despite China threat

A Chinese research vessel entered Sri Lanka's Chinese-run southern port of Hambantota on Tuesday despite concerns from India and the...

Read more

‘No use worrying’: Taiwanese tourists carry on despite China threat

byAFP
August 16, 2022, 12:00 pm
0
146
‘No use worrying’: Taiwanese tourists carry on despite China threat

Visiting Taiwan's tiny Kinmen Islands last week, Joseph Lin practised standing up on his paddleboard, drifting across from the Chinese...

Read more

Advertisement

ADVERTISEMENT
Facebook Twitter Instagram Youtube

ABOUT US

Manila Standard

Manila Standard website (manilastandard.net), launched in August 2002, extends the newspaper’s reach beyond its traditional readers and makes its brand of Philippine news and opinion available to a much wider and geographically diverse readership here and overseas.

Digital Edition

In tone and content, the online edition mirrors the editorial thrust of the newspaper. While hewing to the traditional precepts of fairness and objectivity, MS believes the news of the day need not be staid, overly long or dry. Stories are succinct, readable and written in a lively style that has become a hallmark of the newspaper.

Download – Today’s Paper

Search

No Result
View All Result

6th Floor Universal Re Bldg., 106 Paseo De Roxas cor. Perea Street, Legaspi Village, 1226 Makati City Philippines

Trunklines: 832-5554, 832-5556, 832-5558

© 2021 Manila Standard - Designed and Developed by Neitiviti Studios.

No Result
View All Result
  • About
  • News
    • Top Stories
    • National
    • World News
    • Pinoy Abroad
    • Features
  • Opinion
    • Editorial
    • Columns
    • Soundbytes
  • LGUs
    • NCR
    • Luzon
    • Visayas
    • Mindanao
  • Business
    • Corporate
    • Economy & Trade
    • Stocks
    • Money
    • Agri & Mining
    • Power & Tech
    • IT & Telecom
  • Sports
    • Basketball
    • Volleyball
    • Fightsports
    • Active
    • Sports Plus
    • One Championship
    • Columns
  • Entertainment
    • TV & Movies
    • Celebrity Profiles
    • Music & Concerts
    • Digital Media
    • Columns
  • Lifestyle
    • Food
    • Culture & Media
    • Fashion
    • Health and Home
    • Leisure
    • Shopping
    • Columns
  • Pop.Life
    • Newsmakers
    • Hangouts
    • A-Pop
    • Post Its
    • Performances
    • Malls & Bazaars
    • Hobbies & Collections
  • Technology
    • Gadgets
    • Computers
    • Business
    • Tech Plus
  • MS ON THE ROAD
    • Sedan
    • SUV
    • Truck
    • Bike
    • Accessories
    • Motoring Plus
    • Commuter’s Corner
  • Home & Design
    • Residential
    • Commercial
    • Construction
    • Interior
  • Spotlight
  • Gallery
    • Photos
    • Videos
  • Events
    • Seminars
    • Exhibits
    • Community
  • Biyahero
    • Travel Features
    • Travel Reels
    • Travel Logs
  • Pets
  • Advertise with Us

© 2021 Manila Standard - Designed and Developed by Neitiviti Studios.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Install Manila Standard Web App

Install App